|
WOOL vs.
HAIR
Sheep have been dual-purpose
animals, producing both meat and wool, almost as long
as they have been domesticated. In recent years, however,
several developments have made some producers question
the profitability of wool production.
 |
Synthetic fabrics have taken a portion of the
market and prices paid for many classes of wool
have dropped.
|
 |
Some climates are not suited for quality wool
production.
|
 |
Changing requirements in preparing wool for
market has resulted in added expense, equipment
and labor.
|
 |
Securing shearers can be a problem and may be
delayed by weather.
|
 |
In many areas the cost of shearing has gone up,
especially for small flocks.
|
 |
Shearing requires labor and facilities for gathering
and penning.
|
 |
Wool
can cause management and health problems, especially
in pasture lambing. |
 |
Sheep
can be stressed by gathering, holding off feed and
by exposure to inclement weather after shearing. |
 |
Soiled
wool can be a source of contamination in slaughter
plants. |
 |
When selecting sheep for wool quality, progress
in other valuable traits may be lessened.
|
Unfortunately in many cases
the wool check does not even cover the cost of shearing
and preparation of the wool clip. Besides shearing,
the ewes may also have to be tagged and the lambs shorn
or tagged before being put on feed or marketed, adding
even more labor and expense.
Hair sheep have been raised
in many parts of the world where wool sheep do not thrive.
Many areas in the U.S. have a climate more suited to
raising hair sheep than breeds that originate in Great
Britain. Sheep that are suited to their environment generally
have fewer health problems and require less input in
feed and labor.
Some possible disadvantages
of hair sheep for the present US lamb market are
smaller carcass size, slower growth rate and, presently,
decreased pelt value. Some of the advantages of hair
sheep are extended breeding seasons, high fertility, vigorous
newborn lambs, low labor requirements, parasite resistance,
heat tolerance and increased forage utilization. Most
hair breeds are also well suited for accelerated lambing
systems and managed intensive grazing. The introduction
of the Dorper and White Dorper breeds into the
US has increased the opportunities for production of
fast gaining, high quality lambs in areas suited for
hair sheep.
The decision to change a flock from
wool to non-shearing by using rams of hair breeds on
wooled ewes should be viewed as an ambitious undertaking
requiring several generations to accomplish. In the
worst case there could be years when shearing would
still be necessary but the wool would have to be discarded.
We have worked on the transition from wool to hair
in our commercial flock and would be happy to share
our experiences with you.
top of page
|